Judging by the other reviews, I can only think that either: the other reviewerers haven't been out in two hours of rain or that mine are faulty. THe gloves are pretty warm, but leak on several seams inside where the fingers go. They've leaked in 4 different places and in both gloves so I think it's more than an unlucky bit of stitching. They have however lasted a good 40 to 60 minutes before they leaked in moderate rain. Two stars due to not being waterproof otherwise I'd happily give these 5 stars.