A December trip to Copenhagen and a cold, snowy winter prodded me into buying a properly warm, waterproof coat. My main criteria for the perfect coat were, first, to be knee-length with a hood so it would be cosy yet practical and, second, to not be very bulky or padded, as I didn't fancy looking as if I were wearing a duvet.
This is the perfect coat! It looks stylish and it's so warm that I've been hoping for snow and Siberian winds since I got it just so I can wear it. The quality is very good: firm stitching and stout zips. I love the double-ended zips, which give great flexibility and venting options. The hood is superb, designed to not gape open if you're not wearing it so that rain doesn't collect in it; I think that the optional fake fur attachment gives it the depth to stay on in stiff winds - think a snorkel like Kenny in South Park. The long fleece cuffs are very practical and the pockets are well positioned and a good size. The waterproofing is excellent so far and the length very good for me, being just above the knee.
The only downside is that, in fact, I am often too hot because it's not very breathable without unzipping. I often have to unzip it after walking for 20 mins but the press-studs on the storm-flap are good enough to keep the coat closed so the wind cannot come in yet they do allow some venting. Now I just wear one or two thin merino wool layers underneath, whereas normally in winter I wear layers under a thick jumper. A small negative is that when it's fully zipped up, the top of the stand-up collar goes over my chin and mouth or I have to crush it under my chin. But I appreciate that this is part of the snorkel design.
Overall, I am really happy with this coat. At full price it is much more expensive than I personally would be prepared to pay, however, but I got a large discount and expect it to last for years. All in all, I recommend it, especially if you can bag a bargain.