I bought these gloves for myself and my wife. My hands are on the small side, so as I had no luck finding the men's version in small, I opted for medium in the women's version.
They fit well, have a decent grip and leave you with a good amount of dexterity and sensitivity in your fingers - zips, dog leads, tissues etc. are no problem. The e-tip works also works exceptionally well and works well on all devices with capacitive screens (i.e. all modern touchscreens).
The downside of these gloves is that they are simply not that warm in temperatures below, say, 3-5 degrees Celsius. When walking, I often find my index and middle fingers in particular getting a bit numb!
Overall I would say they are good gloves - fit well, allow you to keep some sensitivity in your hands, and the e-tip works as advertised.
However, as they are not that warm I would say these should be seen as spring/autumn gloves only, or for short winter trips.